This was today’s editorial in the Athens Banner-Herald.
Ex-cheer coach fighting a fight that she picked
EditorialIs there a need to review the role of religion - particularly any Christian evangelizing by coaches - in University of Georgia athletics?
Probably, if just to determine whether any student-athletes feel coerced into accepting creeds they don’t necessarily believe.
But is the lawsuit filed by fired cheerleading coach Marilou Braswell, which suggests there is no standard at UGA for what constitutes acceptable expressions of faith by coaches, a proper vehicle for that review?
Certainly not.
A quick review: In November, Braswell was placed on 12-month probation by athletic association officials following an investigation into complaints by Jaclyn Steele, a Jewish cheerleader, about Christian overtones in the UGA cheerleading program. At that time, Braswell was told to remove all such overtones from the program.
In August of this year, Braswell was fired, after reading a prepared statement to the cheerleading squad telling them of Steele’s complaint, and noting that Steele would be returning to the squad for an unprecedented fourth year, without a tryout. Braswell also expressed her view the complaint was “totally without merit” and told the squad she had hired a lawyer to help make that point.
According to her letter of termination, Braswell was fired for the “discourteous and disruptive behavior” of reading the statement and for singling Steele out as the source of the complaint, in violation of the federal Family Educational and Privacy Rights Act.
But you wouldn’t know that from the Web site Braswell and her husband set up after she was fired.
Take a look at the site - www.helpmarilou.com - and note that in the first sentence on the home page, Braswell and her husband say her “fight vs. the University of Georgia” (a fight that now includes the lawsuit against the athletic association, UGA President Michael Adams, and the University System Board of Regents, seeking unspecified damages) is a result of “her being fired for her Christian beliefs, stance and lifestyle.” And, of course, the site provides information on how to contribute to the Braswell Defense Fund.
It seems Braswell was eager to pick the “fight.” Elsewhere on the Web site home page, Braswell and her husband opine thusly: “We believe that this may be a modern-day ‘Esther’ story, and that Marilou may have been born ‘for such a time as this.”’ (A quick Bible lesson: Esther, who was Jewish, was chosen queen of Persia in the 400s B.C. and was able to thwart a plot aimed at the destruction of the Jewish people. The phrase “for such a time as this” is a reference to a question asked of Esther, “And who knows whether you have not attained royalty for such a time as this?”)
The Braswell Web site goes on to express the belief the ex-coach and her spouse have been specially chosen for the “fight.”
It reads, in part, “Although we would not have chosen for this to happen, we are honored to suffer for the sake of the Gospel. To God be the glory!”
Oh, puh-leez.
First off, Braswell wasn’t fired for “her Christian beliefs, stance and lifestyle.” She was fired because she apparently failed to learn a basic lesson of the workplace. It’s a lesson learned quickly by any 16-year-old who’s ever shoveled popcorn at the local multiplex: When the boss tells you to do something, you do it without complaint - if you want to keep putting gas in the Camaro.
If Braswell had simply complied, quietly, with the directive to keep Steele on the squad, she would still be a cheerleading coach.
Instead, she opted to read her statement, which was more a diatribe than a neutral recitation of circumstances.
It’s true that, late in the statement, Braswell said, “I will not tolerate any negative action, discussion or comments regarding Jackie.” But in the first sentences of the statement, she said she had “retained counsel to investigate the matter and prove my position” that Steele’s allegations were “totally without merit.”
Excuse us, but isn’t hiring an attorney about the most “negative action” one person can take against another?
Was it fair for Steele to get a fourth year on the squad? No. Do we think Steele was sincere in complaining she felt ostracized because of her faith? No.
But should Braswell be bucking for sainthood simply because she couldn’t keep quiet? Emphatically, no.
And finally, while we usually don’t quote Scripture - recognizing that battling with Bible verses is a fruitless exercise - we would suggest Braswell read I Corinthians 13:11. As soon as she decides to climb down from her cross.



Post A Comment